Subscribe & Save Deal | Jif Creamy Peanut Butter — $4.56 per BIG 40 oz jar!

Disclosure Statement

Amazon pricing changes on a dime, so please act quickly to take advantage of this deal and confirm pricing before you check out.

Right now you can score a great deal on Jif Creamy Peanut Butter (40 oz, pack of 2) thanks to a price drop.

These are the BIG jars.

Estimated delivery is May 12.

Click to save

Click over for the current price. Keep in mind that this is displaying the price before the subscription discount.

So if you still see it for around $10.74, that means you’ll pay just $9.13 ($4.56 each) after the 15% discount for having 5 subscriptions in the month.

If you don’t hit that 5-subscription threshold, you’ll save 5% on your subscription order (vs. 15%), making them $5.10 per jar. Still a great deal!

Posting this deal has totally made me crave these! Easiest three ingredient cookies ev-ah.

If you’re new around here, the best way to save at Amazon is when you have five active subscriptions in a month. Then your savings get bumped up from 5% off your subscription to 15%.

If you’re looking for another order or two to bump you up to five total, check out this list of Under $3 Subscribe & Save deals. And don’t forget about all the recent Subscribe & Save deals.

Your subscription order will ship for free, and you can cancel your subscription at any time.

Want to learn more about Amazon’s Subscribe & Save program? Check out this video!

*If you have an Ad Blocker installed on your web browser, you will need to pause it in order to see the widgets. Wondering what’s up with the new Amazon widget, check out this post!


  1. Rachel Steinberg says

    Do you have to have prime in order to do the subscribe and save? I have tried to find this info on the Amazon site and can’t find it anywhere. thanks.

Leave a Comment